
Old Jake Alligood by Dare Wright

Carl Goerch, in his 1956 book, Ocracoke, writes that Old Jake “has never won a beauty contest, and there are folks who will bet you ten to one that he never will. His face is seamy and weather-beaten….He has lost a few of his teeth. There’s one thing, however, about which he is very particular: he shaves once a week and insists upon Little Jake doing the same thing.” In the last few years of his life Old Jake went blind. But he continued to work at his counter. Customers would have to tell him if a bank note was a dollar bill or a five dollar bill. To my knowledge, no one ever tried to cheat him.
Little Jake was skinny, and a man of few words. As Goerch recalled, “Ask Little Jake, ‘Do you think we’ll have good weather tomorrow?’ and he’ll go into deep thought. He’ll consider the matter from every point of view, realizing the seriousness of such a query. Then, after thorough deliberation, he’ll tell you ‘Maybe.'” After Ocracoke became part of the Cape Hatteras National Seashore Little Jake began working for the National Park Service.
Myra was almost always in the store as well, often sitting on one of the benches surveying the scene and keeping order. She was terrified of thunder and lightning storms, cowering in the corner until the tempest abated. She was known to hold forth about living on the island: “All you need on Ocracoke,” she would say, “is what you can put in a suitcase. Anything else you have, the sea will get it.”
Old Jake’s Place was the most popular teenage hangout in the 1950s. Dancing, animated conversation, joking, teasing, and flirting continued until the place closed promptly at 10 pm.

Nearby was a garage where Old Jake and Little Jake worked on cars and trucks. This was also the center for “Jake’s Surf Fishing Taxi” service.They had converted a 1941 WC6, Dodge military weapons carrier, to be able to transport visitors from the Wahab Village Hotel to the beach.

Myra, an island native, had an older son, William (Willie) Hunnings (1913-2000). Willie’s father, Charlie “Winfield” Hunnings (1889-1918), was a Pamlico County native, and Myra’s first husband. Willie moved to Ocracoke with his mother and step-father, Jake Alligood, about 1930, and remained on the island for the rest of his life.
![]() |
| Photo courtesy Ocracoke Preservation Society |
Willie served in the U.S. Army during WWII. On Ocracoke he was seldom seen without his trademark white yachting cap. He made a living painting houses in the 1950s and 1960s. You could also often find him behind the counter of the Community Store. His friendly personality made shopping there a genuine pleasure. Willie enjoyed music, and often sang while he worked. He also played harmonica for the popular island “Graveyard Band.”
In the 1970s and 1980s you could usually find Willie (sometimes called “Three Fingers”…no one seemed to know how he lost his fingers) in his workshop carving birds or sailing ships.
![]() |
| Willie Hunnings Carvings in OPS Museum |
Willie was the grandson of Epherena Fulcher Garrish, Myra’s mother.
In the late 1800s Ocracoke native, Alexander Garrish, fell in love with a young woman. When he asked for her hand in marriage she turned him down. She refused his offer several times, and he finally quit asking. In the meanwhile, Epherena (“Freener”) Fulcher had set her sights on Alexander, and let him know she wanted to marry him. Alexander put Freener off twice. The third time Alexander claimed he had a toothache. Freener is reported to have said, “Heat a brick and put it to his jaw. It’s now or never.” Shortly thereafter the first young woman decided she would accept Alexander’s proposal. “Too late,” Alexander said, “I’ve done promised Freener.” To this day, several islanders still use that phrase when someone fails to take advantage of a chance to do something enjoyable.
(See “Ocracoke” by Carl Goerch, and “Ocracoke in the Fifties” by Brooke Ashley, for more delightful stories and photos about Ocracoke severnty-five years ago.)




